BrothersJudd.com

Home | Reviews | Blog | Daily | Glossary | Orrin's Stuff | Email

The Set of Poe (story) ()


ONE NIGHT after a broadcast on which I had performed one of the lesser-known Fables by George Ade, I took a phone call which turned out to be from S. J. Perelman. He was practically in tears. We exchanged Adeisms for over an hour. It was his considered opinion that Ade was undoubtedly one of the greatest humorists, if not the most outstanding, humorist, America has yet come up with. And what's more, that it was truly sad and ridiculous that the Great Man had become merely a three-letter word meaning "Indiana Humorist" in the New York Times Sunday Crossword Puzzle. A couple of nights later at a late supper in Dinty Moore's, near Broadway, we continued what we had begun over the phone. In addition to remarking on the excellence of the blueberry cheese cake we were consuming, Perelman, in the flush of orgiastic pleasure, went on to say that he felt that Ade had influenced all of the 20th Century American humorists in one way or another and had written about blueberry pie and ice cream as no one ever had or will again.

Up to this point I had felt that Ade was a private little crotchet of my own that I had best conceal from my more literate friends, to be secretly enjoyed when no one was looking, along with other vices such as White Sox shortstops, G-8 And His Battle Aces, old movies starring Merle Oberon, and red cabbage (sweet-sour). After hearing from Sid Perelman, I began to nose around among my other colleagues in the vineyards and immediately uncovered others who lived by Ade's advice, "Don't try to Account for Anything." Among them is the wildly talented cartoonist-writer Shel Silverstein, who supplied me with several rare volumes of Ade to add to the present collection.
    Preface and Introduction to The America of George Ade, 1866-1944 (Jean Shepherd)
George Ade is a literary figure almost impossible for us to imagine today. He was the most popular newspaper columnbist in America–maybe even invented the column?--thanks to his “Stories from the Streets and Town” which he began writing for the Chicago Record in 1893. But he also published numerous books of “Fables” which made him wealthy, wrote plays so popular that he had several performing on Broadway at the same time, and was visited at his home by four Republican presidents, with Taft launching his campaign from the Ade porch. Today we'd need to combine Larry King, Joe Rogan, Lin Manuel Miranda, and more to get such a singular public figure. Suffice it to say that he was one of the most revered humorists of both H. L. Mencken and Jean Shepherd.

Today he gets his props once a year, for his Christas short story, The Set of Poe. Even if I did not tell you that it is often compared to O. Henry, you’ll know where it’s headed from the set-up:
Mr. Waterby remarked to his wife: “I’m still tempted by that set of Poe. I saw it in the window to­day, marked down to fifteen dollars.”

“Yes?” said Mrs. Waterby, with a sudden gasp of emotion, it seemed to him.

“Yes—I believe I’ll have to get it.”

“I wouldn’t if I were you, Alfred,” she said. “You have so many books now.”

“I know I have, my dear, but I haven’t any set of Poe, and that’s what I’ve been wanting for a long time. This edition I was telling you about is beautifully gotten up.”

“Oh, I wouldn’t buy it, Alfred,” she repeated, and there was a note of pleading earnestness in her voice. “It’s so much money to spend for a few books.”

“Well, I know, but—” and then he paused, for the lack of words to express his mortified surprise.

Mr. Waterby had tried to be an indulgent husband. He took a selfish pleasure in giving, and found it more blessed than receiving. Every salary day he turned over to Mrs. Waterby a fixed sum for household expenses. He added to this an allowance for her spending money. He set aside a small amount for his personal expenses and deposited the remainder in the bank.

He flattered himself that he approximated the model husband.

Mr. Waterby had no costly habits and no prevailing appetite for anything expensive. Like every other man, he had one or two hobbies, and one of his particular hobbies was Edgar Allan Poe. He believed that Poe, of all American writers, was the one unmistakable “genius.”

The word “genius” has been bandied around the country until it has come to be applied to a long-haired man out of work or a stout lady who writes poetry for the rural press. In the case of Poe, Mr. Waterby maintained that “genius” meant one who was not governed by the common mental processes, but “who spoke from inspiration, his mind involuntarily taking superhuman flight into the realm of pure imagination,” or something of that sort. At any rate, Mr. Waterby liked Poe and he wanted a set of Poe. He allowed himself not more than one luxury a year, and he determined that this year the luxury should be a set of Poe.

Therefore, imagine the hurt to his feelings when his wife objected to his expending fifteen dollars for that which he coveted above anything else in the world.

As he went to his work that day he reflected on Mrs. Waterby’s conduct.
    -STORY: The Set of Poe ( George Ade)
The joy of the story resides in the way those reflections become obsessive with predictable results. But, if you’re a certain kind of couple, that battle of the books will be quite familiar and, regardless, it’s pretty funny.


(Reviewed:)

Grade: (B+)


Websites:

George Ade Links:

    -WIKIPEDIA: George Ade
    -FILMOGRAPHY: George Ade (IMDB)
    -PLAYOGRAPHY: George Ade (Internet Broadway Database)
    -Hazelden (George Ade House) (Indiana Division of Historic Preservation and Archaeology)
    -ENTRY: George Ade American playwright (Encyclopaedia Britannica)
    -ENTRY: Ade, George (Purdue University)
    -ENTRY: George Ade (Indiana Historical Society)
    -ENTRY: George Ade (Indiana University)
    -ENTRY: George Ade (Indiana Journalism Hall of Fame)
    -ENTRY: George Ade (Indiana Historical Bureau)
    -ENTRY: George Ade (American Literature)
    -ENTRY: George Ade (South Shore Legends)
    -ENTRY: George Ade (Our Land, Our Literature)
    -ENTRY: Ade, George 1866–1944 (Encyclopedia.com)
    -ENTRY: George Ade (Great Forgotten Humorists)
    -ENTRY: George Ade (Playbill)
    -INDEX: George Ade (A-Z Quotes)
    -COLLECTION: George Ade Papers (Smithsonian)
    -INDEX: George Ade (Poem Hunter)
    -INDEX: George Ade (All Poetry)
    -COLLECTION: George Ade Papers (Modern Manuscripts & Archives at the Newberry)
    -DISCOGRAPHY: George Ade (Discography of American Historical Recordings)
    -VIDEO INDEX: “george ade” (YouTube)
    -PODCAST: Index of George Ade stories (Mr. Ron’s Basement)
    -AUDIO INDEX: George Ade (LibriVox)
    -INDEX: Ade, George, 1866-1944 (Internet Archive)
    -ETEXT INDEX: George Ade (Gutenberg)
    -ETEXT INDEX: George Ade (The Online Books Page)
    -
   
-
   
-AUDIO INDEX: Jean Shepherd reads George Ade
    -STORY: The Set of Poe George Ade (1866–1944) (Library of America)
    -AUDIO: “The Set of Poe” (1903) by George Ade (Read by Mark Redfield)
    -AUDIO: THe Set of Poe (Lit Reading)
    -AUDIO STORY: [70] "The Experimental Couple (and the three offshoots)" by George Ade (Morning Shorts, Feb 8, 2017)
    -ESSAY: Mark Twain as Our Emissary George Ade (1866–1944) (From The Mark Twain Anthology: Great Writers on His Life and Works, Library of America)
    -REVIEW ESSAY: Mark Twain and the Old Time Subscription Book (George Ade, June 1910, The American Review of Reviews)
    -ETEXT: Letters of George Ade (Terence University Tobin)
    -
   
-ETEXT: Preface and Introduction to The America of George Ade, 1866-1944 (Jean Shepherd)
    -ESSAY: George Ade, Humorist, Playwright, Columnist – and Champion of a Now-Ubiquitous Word (Allan Metcalf August 20, 2018, Chronicle of Higher Education)
    -ESSAY: George Ade: The Aesop of Indiana (Dean George, 10/26/24, Epoch Times)
    -ESSAY: George Ade (Lucy Sante, February 9, 2011, HiLo Brow)
    -ESSAY: “George Ade, Everybody’s Friend” (Lindsey Beckley, January 10, 2022, Untold Indiana)
    -VIDEO: The Dapper Man Aboiut Town Show & Tell: George Ade (Dr. Pete Bill)
    -ESSAY: George Ade: Worthy Enough to not be Forgotten (Penny Lane, Crown Point Library)
    -ESSAY: American Slang (H.L. Mencken, 1919, The American Language)
    -ESSAY: Significant Sig George Ade, a Man Self-Made (Fran Becque, Ph.D., 2/09/15, Fraternity History)
    -ESSAY: George Ade (1866-1944) (Harold H. Kolb, Jr., Spring 1971, American Literary Realism, 1870-1910)
    -ARTICLE: George Ade, at seventy, begins a new fable (Mildred Gilman, 2/09/36, NY Times Magazine)
    -PODCAST: Episode 25 – A Book and A Beer: George Ade and the Old-Time Saloon (Windy City Historians, October 28, 2021)
    -ARTICLE: George Ade talks of his stage ideals.
    -THESIS: George Ade's Role in National Literature (Albert Riusech, Ouachita Baptist University, 5-1964)
    -PODCAST: George Ade, President Taft, and the Modern Political Campaign (Talking Hoosier History)
    -ESSAY: 3:AM Cult Hero: George Ade (Robert O’Connor. 3AM)
    -ESSAY: How George Ade Introduced Guys to Polite Company (Allan Metcalf, August 30, 2018, Chronicle of Higher Education)
    -ESSAY: A Look at the Language of George Ade (R. F. Bauerle, February 1958, American Speech)
    -ESSAY: George Ade and Vaudeville (Travelanche, 2/09/13)
    -ESSAY: Hazelden and George Ade (Rensselaer Adventures, September 16, 2016)
    -ESSAY: George Ade's Critique of Benevolent Assimilation (Perry E. Gianakos, July 1983, Diplomatic History)
    -REVIEW: of Fables in Slang by George Ade (Noel Perrin, Neglected Books Page)

Book-related and General Links: