BrothersJudd.com

Home | Reviews | Blog | Daily | Glossary | Orrin's Stuff | Email


While overlong at 129 minutes, I've loved John Huston's film version since we were kids. One can't help regretting that he didn't get to make his planned version in the '50s, with Clark Gable and Humphrey Bogart, presumably in black and white, but no one is going to argue with Sean Connery, Michael Caine, Christipher Plummer and Saeed Jaffrey. Somehow though, I'd never read the actual story: it's not even a novella.

The movie is shockingly faithful to the text, including even what seemed like it must be a cinematic framing device, with the story being told in flashback after Peachey returns from Kafiristan. The only real liberty taken there is that the unnamed correspondent of The Northern Star becomes Rudyard Kipling himself. Understandable.

Obviously the story here is politically incorrect and more sensitive souls will be repelled by racist lingo, but it's hard to read events as anything but anti-Imperialist, or, at least, ambivalent about the wisdom of colonialism. Dravot describes his dream to Peachey in idealistic enough terms, but already doubts are creeping in:
“‘I won’t make a Nation,’ says he. ‘I’ll make an Empire! These men aren’t [****]; they’re English! Look at their eyes — look at their mouths. Look at the way they stand up. They sit on chairs in their own houses. They’re the Lost Tribes, or something like it, and they’ve grown to be English. I’ll take a census in the spring if the priests don’t get frightened. There must be a fair two million of ’em in these hills. The villages are full o’ little children. Two million people — two hundred and fifty thousand fighting men — and all English! They only want the rifles and a little drilling. Two hundred and fifty thousand men, ready to cut in on Russia’s right flank when she tries for India! Peachey, man,’ he says, chewing his beard in great hunks, ‘we shall be Emperors — Emperors of the Earth! Rajah Brooke will be a suckling to us. I’ll treat with the Viceroy on equal terms. I’ll ask him to send me twelve picked English — twelve that I know of — to help us govern a bit. There’s Mackray, Sergeant-pensioner at Segowli — many’s the good dinner he’s given me, and his wife a pair of trousers. There’s Donkin, the Warder of Tounghoo Jail; there’s hundreds that I could lay my hand on if I was in India. The Viceroy shall do it for me. I’ll send a man through in the spring for those men, and I’ll write for a dispensation from the Grand Lodge for what I’ve done as Grand-Master. That — and all the Sniders that’ll be thrown out when the native troops in India take up the Martini. They’ll be worn smooth, but they’ll do for fighting in these hills. Twelve English, a hundred thousand Sniders run through the Amir’s country in driblets — I’d be content with twenty thousand in one year — and we’d be an Empire. When everything was ship-shape, I’d hand over the crown — this crown I’m wearing now — to Queen Victoria on my knees, and she’d say:— “Rise up, Sir Daniel Dravot.” Oh, its big! It’s big, I tell you! But there’s so much to be done in every place — Bashkai, Khawak, Shu, and everywhere else.’

“‘What is it?’ I says. ‘There are no more men coming in to be drilled this autumn. Look at those fat, black clouds. They’re bringing the snow.’

“‘It isn’t that,’ says Daniel, putting his hand very hard on my shoulder; ‘and I don’t wish to say anything that’s against you, for no other living man would have followed me and made me what I am as you have done. You’re a first-class Commander-in-Chief, and the people know you; but — it’s a big country, and somehow you can’t help me, Peachey, in the way I want to be helped.’

“‘Go to your blasted priests, then!’ I said, and I was sorry when I made that remark, but it did hurt me sore to find Daniel talking so superior when I’d drilled all the men, and done all he told me.

“‘Don’t let’s quarrel, Peachey,’ says Daniel without cursing. ‘You’re a King too, and the half of this Kingdom is yours; but can’t you see, Peachey, we want cleverer men than us now — three or four of ’em that we can scatter about for our Deputies? It’s a hugeous great State, and I can’t always tell the right thing to do, and I haven’t time for all I want to do, and here’s the winter coming on and all.’ He put half his beard into his mouth, and it was as red as the gold of his crown.
And, of course, Peachey's warning about women and following the letter of the contract is prescient. The two men have benefited greatly from over-awing the natives and convincing them--even if accidentally--that they are gods. But the Imperial project can not withstand the eventual recognition that they are just men, any more than the actual European empires could the realization that all Men are Created equal.

The final bit of license in the film is actually an improvement. When Dravot goes to his death singing The Minstrel Boy it is one of the great scenes in cinema. Kipling has Peachey singing The Son of God Goes Forth to War in one of his last appearances: fine, but lesser.


(Reviewed:)

Grade: (A+)


Websites:

See also:

Rudyard Kipling (4 books reviewed)
Adventure
Short Stories
Rudyard Kipling Links:

    -WIKIPEDIA: Rudyard Kipling
    -The Kipling Society
    -ENTRY: Rudyard Kipling (Poetry Foundation)
    -POEM: If (Rudyard Kipling)
   
-
   
-Rudyard Kipling (1865-1936)(kirjasto)
    -Kipling Society homepage
    -The Nobel Prize in Literature 1907 (Official Site)
    -Rudyard Kipling Winner of the 1907 Nobel Prize in Literature (Nobel Prize Internet Archive)
    -Rudyard Kipling: An Overview (Victorian Web)
    -AITLC  Guide to   Rudyard Kipling (The ACCESS INDIANA Teaching & Learning Center)
    -BIO: Kipling: a Brief Biography  (David Cody, Associate Professor of English, Hartwick College, Victorian Web)
    -Rudyard Kipling (1865-1936)(Ben Freer)
    -Rudyard Kipling (Spartacus)
    -Rudyard Kipling
    -Rudyard Kipling and Scouting
    -ETEXT: The Jungle Books (Project Gutenberg)
    -ANNOTATED ETEXT: The Jungle Book (Self Knowledge)
    -ETEXTS: Rudyard Kipling (Project Gutenberg)
    -ETEXTS: A COMPLETE COLLECTION OF POEMS  BY Rudyard Kipling
    -ETEXTS: Links to Etexts of (Joseph) Rudyard Kipling (Mumbai/Bombay)
    -
   
-ESSAY: Kipling, Kim, and Being a Third Culture Kid (Daniel Shotkin, 9/26/24, 3Quarks)
    -ESSAY: Poetic Prankster: On Rudyard Kipling’s Boundary-Blurring Satire of Bureaucracy: Priyasha Mukhopadhyay Explores the Anglo-Indian Author’s “Departmental Ditties” (Priyasha Mukhopadhyay, September 4, 2024, LitHub)
    -ESSAY: HOW RUDYARD KIPLING'S 'KIM' HELPED CREATE MODERN ESPIONAGE: Kipling's tale of imperial adventure whipped Britain into a frenzy for spies. Soon, a new agency was created. (HUGH WILFORD, 6/13/24, CrimeReads0
    -ARTICLE: Marlboro Journal; 1892 Bank Box Opens A Lid on Kipling's Past  (FOX BUTTERFIELD, The New York Times)
    -ESSAY: Rudyard Kipling &  the god of things as they are  (John Derbyshire, New Criterion)
    -ESSAY: Diamonds are forever? Kipling's imperialism (Denis Judd, History Today)
    -ESSAY: Summary of the Mowgli Stories
    -ESSAY: Rudyard Kipling and Tacoma (Tacoma Public Library)
    -ESSAY: Kipling and Freemasonry (Grand Lodge Webmaster, Grand Lodge of British Columbia)
    -REVIEW: of THE JUNGLE BOOK By Rudyard Kipling. Illustrated by  Michael Foreman GUNGA DIN By Rudyard Kipling. Illustrated by Robert Andrew Parker (Jonathan Cott, NY Times Book Review)
    -REVIEW: of RUDYARD KIPLING A Life By Harry Ricketts (RICHARD BERNSTEIN, NY Times)
    -REVIEW: John Bayley: Paleface, NY Review of Books
        Rudyard Kipling and His World by Kingsley Amis
        Kipling: The Glass, the Shadow and the Fire by Philip Mason
    -REVIEW: V.S. Pritchett: A Gentle-Violent Man, NY Review of Books
        The Strange Ride of Rudyard Kipling: His Life and Works by Angus Wilson
    -REVIEW: V. S. Pritchett: Contradictory Kipling, NY Review of Books
        Rudyard Kipling by Lord Birkenhead
    -REVIEW: of QUEST FOR KIM By Peter Hopkirk (RICHARD BERNSTEIN, NY times)
 

FILM:
    -BUY IT: The Jungle Book (1967)(Amazon.com)
    -Review of RUDYARD KIPLING'S THE JUNGLE BOOK 1994 (Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times)

Book-related and General Links:

    -ENTRY: The Man who Would be King (notes by John McGivering and George Kieffer, The Kipling Society)
    -WIKIPEDIA: The Man Who Would Be King
    -RADIO PLAY: The Man Who Would Be King: BBC Radio Drama (BBC Radio 4, 2018-07-07)
    -ETEXT: The Man Who Would Be King (Project Gutenberg)
    -AUDIO: The Man Who Would Be King (Bookstream)
    -AUDIO: The Man Who Would Be King (Librivox)
    -ENTRY: The Man Who Would Be King (Encyclopaedia Britannica)
    -ENTRY: The Man Who Would Be King (Encyclopedia.com)
    -STUDY GUIDE: The Man Who Would Be King (LitCharts)
    -STUDY GUIDE: The Man Who Would Be King (SuperSummary)
    -STUDY GUIDE: The Man Who Would Be King (eNotes)
    -STUDY GUIDE: The Man Who Would Be King (CourseHero)
    -STUDY GUIDE: The Man Who Would Be King (Bookey)
    -STUDY GUIDE: The Man Who Would Be King (GradeSaver)
    -STUDY GUIDE: The Man Who Would Be King (Wendy Reads Books)
    -STUDY GUIDE: The Man Who Would Be King (BookRags)
    -STUDY GUIDE: The Man Who Would Be King (TV Tropes)
    -STUDY GUIDE: The Man Who Would Be King ()
    -ESSAY: Feminist and New Historicist Readings of Kipling's "The Man Who Would Be King" (Kelley S. Kent, 2015, Inquiries)
    -ESSAY: God and His Doubles: Kipling and Conrad's 'The Man who would be King' (KAORI NAGAI, 2009, Critical Survey)
    -ESSAY: 'The Man Who Would Be King'(1888): Rudyard Kipling's Last Imperial Story (Richard Ambrosini, May 2017, Nordic Journal of English Studies(
    -ESSAY: Framing and Distancing in Kipling's "The Man Who Would Be King" (Thomas A. Shippey and Michael Short, May 1972, The Journal of Narrative Technique)
    -ESSAY: WHITENESS, MISCEGENATION, AND ANTI-COLONIAL REBELLION IN RUDYARD KIPLING’S THE MAN WHO WOULD BE KING (Sharleen Mondal, 9/19/24, Victorian Literature and Culture)
    -ESSAY: The American West: That Time Rudyard Kipling Came To Yellowstone And Wasn’t Impressed: Rudyard Kipling was in a foul and despicable mood when his editor sent him to visit America. He was not impressed with the American West. "Today I am in the Yellowstone Park, and I wish I were dead," he wrote. (Terry A. Del Bene, June 22, 2024, Cowboy State Daily)
    -ARCHIVES: “rudyard kipling” (Internet Archives)
    -VIDEO ARCHIVES: “man who would be king (You Tube)
    -REVIEW: of The Man Who Would Be King ( (NASRULLAH MAMBROL, Literary Theory and Criticism)
    -REVIEW: of The Man Who Would Be King (The Reading Bug)
    -REVIEW: of The Man Who Would Be King (BooksPlease)
    -REVIEW: of The Man Who Would Be King (ScriblerusClub)
    -REVIEW: of The Man Who Would Be King (Book Around the Corner)
    -REVIEW: of The Man Who Would Be King (
    -REVIEW: of The Man Who Would Be King (Too Many Posts)
    -REVIEW: of The Man Who Would Be King (Vacuous Wastrel)

FILM:

    -FILMOGRAPHY: The Man Who Would Be King (1975) (IMDB)
    -WIKIPEDIA: John Huston
    -FILMOGRAPHY: Rudyard Kipling (IMDB)
    -FILMOGRAPHY: John Huston (IMDB)
    -WIKIPEDIA: The Man Who Would Be King (film)
    -FILMOGRAPHY: The Man Who Would Be King (Rotten Tomatoes)
    -MOVIE SCRIPT: The Man Who Would Be King (Scripts.com)
    --SCENE: Great Death Scenes Daniel Dravot - The Man who would be King
    -FILM REVIEW: The Man Who Would Be King (Pauline Kael, The New Yorker)
    -FILM REVIEW: The Man Who Would Be King (Roger Moore, Movie Nation)
    -FILM REVIEW: The Man Who Would Be King (British Empire)